> From: John P. Schneider <schneids@centuryinter.net>
> My working definition of meme is not as strict; it is something like:
> 'meme = reproducible concept'. In just about any transmission I've
> ever made where I've used the word 'meme', you could replace it with
> 'idea' and not change the meaning at all.
If meme=idea and idea=meme, then meme has no real meaning. It is
a ploy to attract attention.
"Hey you guys I've got an idea" becomes "Hey you guys I've got a meme"
If it quack's like an idea, acts like an idea, an smells like an idea
why call anything else other then an idea?
> I think the language of memetics has been stretched a bit. My def'n
> of 'meme' is rather loose compared to other definitions. If I double-
> check the definition over at the 'memetic lexicon page', I see that it
> is much closer to what you have. Under that strict meaning, I may end
> up agreeing that memes don't exist. But, that will not stop me from
> pursuing my thoughts concerning 'reproducible ideas'. If ever I want
> to learn about hypnotism or NLP, then a stronger version of 'meme'
> may aid my understanding.... as it happens, however, I know very
> little about such.
We need to discuss what others mean by the idea of memes then.
> > Some things to ponder while discussing this are: Is racism just a
> > "good idea" or is it a meme?
> Meme, I would guess.
Let's not guess. Let's find out for sure.
> > Has anyone ever really encountered a meme in their personal life?
> Various 'habits' maybe? Fashion? Belief in God? Conservativism,
> liberalism? Chauvinism, etc...
Those are *symptoms* of memes and not memes in themselves.
> > What are the minimum "system requirements" for a meme to success-
> > fully exist (In other words, can retarded or semi-retarded people
> > be infected with the same memes as normal people can?)?
> They must be capable of some individual behavior, I would think...
> that way, we might note how that behavior is modified when infected
> by a new meme.... for instance, in the movie, "The Rain Man", Tom
> Cruise infects Dustin Hoffman with the 'fashion meme' (causing him
> to say "K-Mart sucks".)
I think that one of the requirements is the ability to blindly follow directions
...but is that possible? Memes would have to be very rare then.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Thu May 23 2002 - 04:00:35 MDT