virus: How the Shaman Paid

Ken McE (KenMce@catskill.net)
Wed, 13 Aug 1997 22:43:44 -0500


This is a multi-part message in MIME format.

--------------501627EC5B72
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

The article below states that someone was doing Trepanations (removal
of a piece of the skull, without killing you, for medical purposes) in
neolithic France, around 7,000 years ago. I would like to suggest that
your run of the mill hunter or gatherer is not a good candidate for this
kind of work

Further, I speculate that what we now call "Shamans" would be the
persons most likely to be doing this sort of thing. Archeological
evidence suggests that this person performed delicate surgery quite
competently, with none of the products of modern technological
civilization assisting them, a feat that we would be hard pressed to
duplicate today.

If they claimed to have divine knowledge, or if folks just assumed it,
that's fine. People today still atribute semi-magical powers to
doctors. The important thing is that they had useful skills, and used
them for the good of the tribe. Kind of takes the "sham" out of Shaman,
doesn't it?

The below was taken from the September 1997 edition of Discovery
Magazine. The full text is available at:

http://www.enews.com:80/magazines/discover/magtxt/9709-2.html


ARCHEOLOGY Stone Age Surgery

TO RELIEVE PRESSURE
from
bleeding after a blow to
the
head, surgeons often drill or cut
into the skull to allow fluids to drain.

(snip)

One grave held the remains of a 50-year-old man who
had two holes in his skull. Both holes were
remarkably free of surrounding cracks and were
clearly the result of surgery, not violence.

(snip)

Both holes had time to heal before the man
died-the smaller hole is completely covered over
with a thin layer of bone; the larger is roughly
two-thirds covered-and neither shows signs of
infection. "So they must have had a very good
surgeon, and there must have been some way or
another of avoiding infection,"

(snip)

"The trepanations were done so perfectly that this
can't be the oldest one," Pichler says. "They must
have practiced somehow, and the knowledge of
how to do this kind of operation must have been
passed down," Pichler says. "The fact that there are
two trepanations is further corroboration: if there
had been just one, you could say that they were
lucky. But if you survived two such operations,
your surgeon must have known what he was doing."

--------------501627EC5B72
Content-Type: text/html; charset=us-ascii; name="9709-2.html"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Disposition: inline; filename="9709-2.html"
Content-Base: "http://www.enews.com:80/magazines/disc
over/magtxt/9709-2.html"

<BASE HREF="http://www.enews.com:80/magazines/discover/magtxt/9709-2.html">

Discover Magazine September 1997
    DISCOVER MAGAZINE

    September 1997


    Breakthroughs

    Index:

    BIOLOGY
    Popping Polyps

    ALTHOUGH LARGELY sedentary, corals are extravagant builders. Over millions of years, the shells of these tiny animals can accumulate into sprawling structures like Australia's 80,000-square-mile Great Barrier Reef. Corals grow and conquer new territory in two ways. Individual polyps-mature coral animals-divide asexually, producing clones; coral polyps also reproduce sexually, releasing their eggs and sperm into the water. The resulting generation of free-swimming larvae eventually anchor themselves to the seafloor, mature into polyps, and begin a new reef.

    Biologists have believed that all corals reproduced in these ways. But marine biologist Esti Kramarsky-Winter at Tel Aviv University recently found corals that use a very different propagation strategy. Shallow water corals in the Red Sea and on the Mediterranean coast of Israel eject fully formed polyps from their midst to pioneer colonies.

    While diving in the Gulf of 'Aqaba in Israel, Kramarsky-Winter came upon some vigorous colonies of the coral Favia favus. She soon discovered that these colonies, in addition to spawning sexually like most corals, grew crops of fully formed polyps on short stems made of calcium carbonate. Somehow the polyps pop off their stems, and the ejected animals, carried by currents, start new colonies as far as ten feet from the parent reef. When Kramarsky-Winter harvested a few polyps and brought them back to the lab, they cloned new colonies within two months. She has since found another coral, Oculina patagonica, that has popping polyps.

    Kramarsky-Winter doesn't yet know how the popping mechanism works, but its advantages are clear. The release of mature polyps, she says, helps coral compensate for the hazards of sexual reproduction. Heavy waves can foil a coral colony's attempts to spawn, sweeping away immature larvae before they have a chance to settle down and begin cloning a new colony. "The polyp emerges fully formed, so it has many fewer stages to go through than a larva," says Kramarsky-Winter.


    ARCHEOLOGY
    Stone Age Surgery

    Ancient skull with trepanations TO RELIEVE PRESSURE from bleeding after a blow to the head, surgeons often drill or cut into the skull to allow fluids to drain. But people figured out the advantages of the procedure long before the advent of modern surgery. Trepanation, the removal of bone from the skull, is the most ancient surgical technique known. Archeologists have found trepanned skulls dating from the late Neolithic, some 5,000 years ago. Now a team of French and German researchers has suggested that the procedure goes back even further, to at least 7,000 years ago.

    The evidence comes from the French village of Ensisheim. To date, archeologists there have unearthed 45 graves containing 47 individuals. One grave held the remains of a 50-year-old man who had two holes in his skull. Both holes were remarkably free of surrounding cracks and were clearly the result of surgery, not violence. One hole, in the frontal lobe, is about 2.5 inches wide; the second, at the top of the skull, is about an inch wider.

    "Most questionable trepanations are rather small, and with some you cannot tell the shape of the original hole that was made within the skull, or whether it was a fracture," says archeologist Sandra Pichler of Freiburg University in Germany, a member of the team. "But in our case you can still see the very straight, slanting edges of the larger trepanation, and this is artificial. There is no natural explanation for a hole like that."

    Both holes had time to heal before the man died-the smaller hole is completely covered over with a thin layer of bone; the larger is roughly two-thirds covered-and neither shows signs of infection. "So they must have had a very good surgeon, and there must have been some way or another of avoiding infection," Pichler says. Pichler and her colleagues estimate that it would take at least six months, and perhaps as much as two years, for such extensive healing. Since the two holes did not heal to the same degree, it's likely they were made during two separate operations.

    The team doesn't know why the man was operated on. Nor can they be sure exactly how the trepanations were performed, although the cut marks indicate that the bone was removed by a mixture of cutting and scraping. Stone Age tools were certainly up to the task: flint knives are actually sharper than modern scalpels.

    "The trepanations were done so perfectly that this can't be the oldest one," Pichler says. "They must have practiced somehow, and the knowledge of how to do this kind of operation must have been passed down," Pichler says. "The fact that there are two trepanations is further corroboration: if there had been just one, you could say that they were lucky. But if you survived two such operations, your surgeon must have known what he was doing."

    Image: Kurt W. Alt


    Floating Frog

    Floating frog This little frog, floating weightlessly, was not photographed aboard the space shuttle but right here on Earth. Jan Kees Maan and Andre Geim, physicists at the University of Nijmegen in the Netherlands, used a powerful magnet to levitate the frog. Any living thing, when placed in a magnetic field, itself becomes a magnet as the atoms in its cells try to shift their electrons to oppose the external magnetic field. This effect is usually very weak, but in a field 100,000 times that of Earth's, the force produced is strong enough to cancel gravity and levitate the object, in this case a frog (which seems to have suffered no ill effects). Apart from levity, Maan says the experiment has a practical side. Scientists can now test microgravity experiments before--or instead of--sending them up in a space shuttle. "You come as close as you can possibly get on Earth to spacelike conditions," says Maan.

    Photograph courtesy Jan Kees Maan, University of Nijmegen


    Penguin Power

    Simulate penguin propulsion boat
    Boston's Charles River is the early-morning training ground for at least three collegiate rowing teams and now for one remote-controlled penguin boat. This unusual 12-foot vessel is the first step in using simulated penguin propulsion to bring down the cost, both monetary and environmental, of worldwide shipping. Proteus, as the penguin boat is dubbed, uses rigid flippers instead of propellers. The flippers create less turbulence than propellers, so more of their energy goes into pushing the boat forward. For a given speed, Proteus uses 17 percent less power than a propeller-driven craft of similar dimensions. Proteus's handler, James Czarnowski, who developed the boat while at MIT, says that conversion of even a small fraction of the U.S. shipping fleet to such efficient propulsion would save tens of millions of dollars and hundreds of millions of gallons of fuel annually. Czarnowski must overcome just one difficulty before he can develop a full-size 140-foot test boat. He must develop a steering mechanism. He doesn't see this as a difficult task. With a little tinkering, he says, the flippers could also serve as rudders.

    Photograph: Donna Coveney/MIT


    ASTRONOMY
    A Halo of Suns

    MOST GALAXIES, including our own Milky Way, present only part of themselves to our eyes. They hide much of their mass in huge halos that envelop the more conspicuous spirals. Astronomers know the halo matter is there because it affects the motions of stars in galaxies. But they don't know what it is. "It's hard to infer the properties of stuff you don't see," says Rick Rudy, an astronomer with the Aerospace Corporation in Los Angeles.

    Rudy believes he may have partly solved the mystery. In 1994 astronomers found a faint gauzy glow around NGC 5907, a galaxy about 36 million light-years away. The glow seemed consistent with the size and shape of the matter needed to make NGC 5907 spin the way it does, so astronomers hoped that this might be the first sign that the dark halos were made of ordinary stars and planets--albeit faint ones--rather than exotic, yet-to-be discovered particles.

    Rudy and Chick Woodward of the University of Wyoming recently studied this glow to see what sort of stars caused it. Based on the infrared signature of the faint light, they found to their surprise that the glow seems to be created by second- and third-generation stars-stars created out of gas and dust that has been cooked in the hearts of very large, short-lived stars. "The colors you expect from a star depend on its composition," Rudy says. "Stars made of primordial material have peculiar colors." But what Rudy and Woodward saw around NGC 5907 resembled the light emitted by stars the size of our sun and smaller.

    Rudy and Woodward estimate that most of the glow comes from a population of small, dim red stars with about a tenth of the mass of the sun. The mysterious mass of the halo of at least one galaxy thus comes from relatively dim bulbs that were simply too faint for earlier generations of instruments to detect.

    Before astronomers can put the question of the halo mass to rest, however, they must still explain our Milky Way: the Hubble Space Telescope has not found large numbers of small red stars swarming in our halo. If both of these studies hold up, astronomers may have another mystery on their hands--why two seemingly ordinary galaxies have halos made of different kinds of stuff.


    ANCIENT LIFE
    The Trouble With Trilobites

    DURING THEIR HEYDAY in the Cambrian Period, some 500 million years ago, trilobites were as common and as diverse as their crustacean cousins are today. These shelled arthropods crawled on seafloors the world over. Some were fingernail size; others as long as a foot. Yet despite that early success, by 250 million years ago they had vanished from the world's oceans. What happened to them? Some researchers speculate that predators--including primitive jawed fish--wiped them out. "There is a precipitous decline in trilobite diversity as the predator groups got more abundant," says Danita Brandt, a paleontologist at Michigan State University. But Brandt doubts that predation alone can explain the trilobites' demise. Modern crustaceans, she points out, have no trouble surviving in predator-filled waters.

    Brandt thinks another factor may have decided the trilobites' fate: the way they molted. Like all arthropods, trilobites were encased in a hard protective exoskeleton that they had to shed periodically in order to grow. "Each molt is a crisis," says Brandt. "During molting the animal is very vulnerable to predators. They shed their hard exoskeleton and then run around--actually, they hide--with this soft new skeleton, which can take hours to harden. And things can go wrong in the process of shedding: an appendage can get stuck in the exoskeleton, and the animal can get injured."

    Presumably to minimize that danger, all modern crustaceans have standardized the molting process. "They molt the same way every time," Brandt says. "In shrimp, a suture opens up between the front half of the exoskeleton and the back, and the animal pops out; crabs also have a suture that opens up every time." Even horseshoe crabs, ancient relatives of crustaceans that have remained virtually unchanged for at least the past 400 million years, always molt in exactly the same way.

    Not so for the hapless trilobites. When Brandt studied thousands of fossilized molted exoskeletons from the genus Flexicalymene, she found that most of the time a suture would open up across the head, and the animal would neatly fall out. But sometimes, it seems, that clean suture failed to open; instead a crack split the segments on the trilobite thorax, and the trilobite then wriggled out as best it could, sometimes getting entangled in the process. Molting in at least a dozen other trilobites has been studied by other researchers; none show a consistent pattern.

    "I won't go so far as to say that this inefficient molting habit is the reason the trilobites are extinct," Brandt says. "If it had been a problem from the beginning, we wouldn't have seen this huge diversity. What I am suggesting is that an inefficient molt habit plus an increase in predators may have been a one-two punch they couldn't recover from."


    Occupational Hazards of Monkdom

    Around 500 A.D., the Byzantine monastery of St. Stephen, just outside Jerusalem, was a bustling refuge for up to 10,000 monks. Custom dictated that when a monk died, his body was put in a crypt beneath the monastery. When the body had decomposed, the bones went into a repository. Susan Sheridan, an anthropologist at Notre Dame, has studied some 6,000 of these bones and found that the monks were a fairly robust group. "They were the healthiest population I've ever studied," says Sheridan, except in one respect--almost all the monks seem to have had arthritic knees. Many of their kneecaps' edges were worn smooth and shiny as a result of rubbing directly against their thighbones. Sheridan saw the characteristic roughening of arthritis at the points where muscles used in kneeling attach to the bone. Historical records show that the monks spent an impressive amount of time kneeling; praying at midnight, sunrise, twice during the day, at sunset, and again at night. One monk wrote about his nightly practice of descending 18 steps into a holy cave and making 100 genuflections on each step. "If you think about what that's doing to your legs as you come up and down that hard pavement," says Sheridan, "you can do some damage."


    ARCHEOLOGY
    Ancient Abuse

    Ancient Egyptian daggers WHEN ARCHEOLOGIST Brenda Baker unearthed a 4,000-year-old female skeleton from a cemetery at Abydos--an ancient Egyptian provincial town about 100 miles north of Luxor--her examination of the bones suggested that the woman had been fatally stabbed in the back when she was about 35, perhaps with a dagger like one of those shown here. Her left rear fifth and sixth ribs were sliced, and no new bone had been laid down--a sign that the wound never had time to heal.

    But according to Baker, who works at the New York State Museum in Albany, the woman's troubles probably began long before her violent death. Her body bore the signs of a lifetime of abuse. Three ribs and a bone in her left hand had been fractured and had subsequently healed. A break in her right wrist showed signs of infection-channels in the bone that probably formed to drain away pus.

    The pattern of injuries--some healed, some not--suggests that the wounds were not the result of one accident. Her injuries resemble those of battered women, who frequently suffer broken ribs when punched or kicked in the chest. The fractured wrist probably resulted from an attempt to break a fall.

    Although healed fractures can be seen in two male skeletons from the site--one had a dent in the skull, the other a broken arm--the woman's injuries were by far the most extensive. She was probably a farmer or a householder, says Baker, since she was buried in a simple wooden coffin in the sand in an area reserved for common people, many of whose bones showed signs of malnutrition and osteoarthritis-afflictions often found in manual laborers. So she may have been an abused servant in an elite household. Alternatively, her assailant could have been her husband or father.

    The woman's skeleton--and those of others around her--reveals a great deal about the lives of Egyptian working women in the second millennium B.C. "Seeing these skeletons helps us learn something about the kinds of conditions that they survived," says Baker. Or, in this woman's case, did not.

    Photograph courtesy Brenda Baker; daggers on display at the Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto


    Bat Spit

    The sugary, acidic diet of a fruit bat would corrode the teeth of just about any other mammal. But fruit bats don't have problems with tooth decay. Anatomist Elizabeth Dumont of Northeastern Ohio Universities College of Medicine thought that the saliva of fruit bats might buffer the acids in their food, thus protecting their teeth. To find out, she measured the acidity of saliva from a number of species of fruit bat. In some bats the pH dropped close to 5.5, the acidity at which human teeth begin to decay. To Dumont's surprise, the saliva of some old-world fruit bats was just as acidic after their food had cleared the mouth and digestive system, 20 minutes later, and remained so for six hours. She isn't sure why the bats' teeth don't rot, but she thinks the acidity of their saliva may help bats extract all the nutrients they can from their food. "Fruit is a low-quality food," Dumont says, "so the bats draw a little more food out in the short 20 minutes they have to get it."


    © Copyright 1997 The Walt Disney Company

    Current Issue Discover Awards Discover TV Editors' Web Tour
    Archive Library For Educators Marketplace Behind the Scenes



    Webmaster
    webmaster@discover.com

    Talk to Us Subscribe Return to Top Page

    --------------501627EC5B72--