RE: virus: Mother-Daughter Dating

Jeff Rotter (rotterj@bandai.com)
Wed, 19 Feb 1997 11:26:09 -0800


------ =_NextPart_000_01BC1E57.B54AD6A0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

I've been mailbombed, so please do not send me anymore info. There is legal action pending.

----------
From: Reed Konsler[SMTP:konsler@ascat.harvard.edu]
Sent: Wednesday, February 19, 1997 8:44 AM
To: virus@maxwell.lucifer.com
Subject: virus: Mother-Daughter Dating

>From: zaimoni@ksu.edu
>Date: Tue, 18 Feb 1997 11:13:38 -0600 (CST)
>Subject: Re: virus: Mother-Daughter Dating
>
>On Fri, 14 Feb 1997, Reed Konsler wrote:
>
>> Zamboni wrote:
>> >The assumption I balk at is this: the starting level of a
>> >mother-daughter
>> >based dating method is ALWAYS 100% mother, 0% daughter.
>>
>> Richard wrote:
>> >I agree this is true in most cases. However, there have been
>> >well-documented cases in which experimenters have dated the DAUGHTER
>> >first, only to progress to dating the mother some months later. These
>> >cases, however, almost always involve some intentionality on the part of
>> >the mother and so may perhaps be discounted.
>>
>> Sad to say this is yet another example of antiquated cutural practices
>>standing
>> in the way of the advancement of science. In order to be completely
>>rigourous
>> it would be necessary for the researchers to engage in double-blind dating
>> with a randomized sample of mothers and daughters. I've heard of some
>> attempts to reduce this to practice, but not in any repudable publications.
>
>The above context has nothing to do with geology.

WARNING: THE ABOVE STATEMENT WAS A JOKE, IRONIC, WITTY (well, so I thought)

Are you being intentionally dense? Are you trying to make a point by
screwing with my mind? Did you read the above exchange and NOT realize the
context of the argument had changed? If you really thought I was serious I
am dumbfounded by my own inability to communicate humor. Maybe I should
stick to chemistry.

>An example of appropriate context is this: [cut out the details]

blah, blah. No offense, but I'm a scientist and I live in a world of
technical shit as it is. All I can say is that it is easy to criticise
people's thinking but difficult to offer an alternative. Language is used
differently in different sciences and the standards of evidence, proof and
logic vary. No sub-set of the scientific mind is like the "culture" which
most Westerners share. I frankly have no idea if those hacks in Geology
know their ass from a hole in the ground...but I trust that as fellow
scientists they are trying to strike a match in the dark...even if they end
up lighting their own farts most of the time. If radiodating is fucked
then eventually we will figure it out and replace our current understanding
with another. The details of it don't interest me at this time.

I'm sorry, I really don't mean to offend. I think I'm just stunned that my
sophomoric intention at humor went unrecognized...unappreciated, now that
I'm used to...but to be interpreted seriously?

Dazed and Confused,

Reed

---------------------------------------------------------------------
Reed Konsler konsler@ascat.harvard.edu
---------------------------------------------------------------------

------ =_NextPart_000_01BC1E57.B54AD6A0
Content-Type: application/ms-tnef
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
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=

------ =_NextPart_000_01BC1E57.B54AD6A0--