Author
|
Topic: Afghanistan: And the wheels kept falling off in all directions (Read 2975 times) |
|
Blunderov
Archon
Gender: 
Posts: 3160
Reputation: 8.90
Rate Blunderov
"We think in generalities, we live in details"
  
|
 |
Re:Afghanistan: And the wheels kept falling off in all directions
« Reply #30 on: 2010-03-29 12:12:28 » |
 |
[Blunderov] I read a very interesting comment by someone on a Democratic Underground thread (sadly, I've misplaced it) who makes the point that Obama is a poker player, not a chess player, and that if he was "all in" (on health reform), then so were the Republicans. Perhaps Obama now has the political capital to fix the absurd mess that is Afghanistan?
It's perhaps worth reflecting that the Geopolitical Chessboard is probably a misnomer: in chess the opponents both command perfect information of the game before them, and there is almost no scope for bluff. The reverse is true of poker and also geopolitics.
With regard to Afghanistan, the element of bluff has escalated into an obvious fraud by the US and it's somewhat less than willing allies. Such is the brazeness of this fraud that the main "reason" usually given for persisting in Afghanistan, the prevention of the Taliban from regaining power, atracts only passing interest. But a closer scrutiny might reveal the open admission of the worst possible war crime: the waging of an aggressive war. Unless I am mistaken, the Taliban was a perfectly legal government before the US ousted them. That original act of ousting them was an illegal war which intended regime change and had nothing to do with self defence. To continue to pusue this very same objective is just as illegal as it ever was.
http://www.opednews.com/articles/Turkey-in-Afghanistan-Oba-by-Dave-Lindorff-100329-964.html
Turkey in Afghanistan: Obama Sneaks into Kabul to Plead with Karzai to Clean Up His Act
By Dave Lindorff
March 29, 2010
For OpEdNews
How pathetic a scene was this: The president of the United States, commander- in-chief of the mightiest war machine the world has ever known, sneaking into one of the poorest countries in the world and meeting with the corrupt leader of that country, where he has committed 100,000 troops to battle, to beg with that corrupt leader to "clean up" his corrupt and profoundly inept government.
Already, a thousand American soldiers as well as many civilian aid workers, not to mention tens of thousands of innocent Afghans, have died in an eight-year war that the US launched in 2001, originally with the intent solely of ousting the existing Taliban government and destroying the bases of mostly Arab fighters who had been assisting the Taliban in their fight against Russian-allied warlords.
Over the years, with the Al Qaeda fighters destroyed or pushed out of Afghanistan, the war has grown and morphed into a grinding and so far losing battle against indigenous Taliban fighters and Afghan nationalists and tribalists who are trying trying to drive out the US. But after eight years of fighting, the goal of the war, on the American side, has only become less and less clear.
That goal now appears to be: crushing the Taliban and creating a modern, functioning nation state with a government that at least has the grudging respect of the populace.
But none of that is really likely to happen.
The US military recently staged a fake, movie-set battle in a rural area of southeastern Afghanistan, claiming it was assaulting a large town of 80,000, allegedly infested with Taliban fighters--an alleged center of the insurgency. With the support of an either duped or incredibly corrupt US press corps, the military went into the area, which was actually a group of scattered farming villages with a central market, claiming it would operate under new rules of engagement designed to protect civilians, and then, after clearing out the Taliban, set up a model government administration.
Things went badly from the start, when the Marines fired a rocket salvo into a home and killed 12 innocent civilians, including children. In the end some 30 civilians were killed, very few actual Taliban fighters were killed or captured, as they fled the scene in the weeks leading up to the highly advertised offensive, and to cap it off, the Afghan soldiers who hung behind as the Marines went into the area, when they did finally enter the battle zone themselves, proceeded to strip the market area, stealing anything of value.
A new "mayor" brought in from outside to administer the "liberated" Marjah region, turned out to be a killer and a thug. So far, a month after the end of the fighting in Marjah, there is no clean new administration there, and there probably never will be. The focus of the US military is now on the one-million population city of Kandahar.
Good luck to the civilians living there.
Gen. Stanley McChrystal, the commander of the war in Afghanistan, scraped together a cheering section of 2500 US marines and soldiers to give some "Boo-yahs!" to the visiting commander-in-chief, but it's hard to believe that the rest of the over 70,000 US troops in the country are cheering. (And forget the NATO "allies," most of whom are preparing to pack it up and go home.)
The government US forces are propping up is so weak and corrupt that it doesn't really "rule" anything but the capital city of Kabul, and it, and its police and army enforcers, are largely viewed by the majority of Afghans as little more than an official mafia. It is well known that President Hamid Karzai stole the last election and thumbed his nose at world opinion (his opponent simply quit the race in disgust during the ballot counting).
And it was this usurper Karzai whom the visiting Obama was left to plead with to clean up the mess of a government he runs. Clean up how? Karzai's own brother is a leading warlord and opium baron. Even the country's opium crap is being left untouched by US forces, for fear of alienating the country's farmers, so we're actually in there fighting to defend the world's leading producer of opium for the heroin trade! How on earth do you "clean up" a government in a country like that?
Incredibly, as stupid and pointless and immoral as was the war in Iraq, Obama has found himself mired in an even more stupid, pointless and immoral war in Afghanistan. And because he has chosen, in his first year in office, to escalate that war instead of wind it down and end it, and has doubled the rate of US casualties in that war, President Obama now cannot do the right thing and end it even if he wants to, because then, how to explain all those pointless deaths? Instead, he is forced to clap soldiers, perhaps some of them already doomed, on the back in the cafeteria at Bagram Air Base, and tell them, in an echo or George Bush's famous sneak visit to Iraq, "I'm proud of you. You guys are doing great work, each and every day."
What a pathetic joke. The only thing missing was the plastic turkey.
Dave Lindorff's writing is available at www.thiscantbehappening.net. He is a columnist for Counterpunch, is author of several recent books ("This Can't Be Happening! Resisting the Disintegration of (more...)
|
|
|
|
|
MoEnzyme
Acolyte
Gender:
Posts: 2256
Reputation: 4.69
Rate MoEnzyme
infidel lab animal
|
|
Re:Afghanistan: And the wheels kept falling off in all directions
« Reply #31 on: 2010-03-29 23:53:31 » |
|
Blunderov,
I don't really think Obama started off on health care being all in, although perhaps in response to the GOP he became all in. And of course winning that, he is somewhat more empowered than before. In re: to Afghanistan, I do think that he has always been all in on that from even before he was in DC. While still a state senator, Obama gave a very eloquent speech about this before the Iraq invasion, about how he saw the Taliban in Afghanistan as the righteous target (for hosting Al Qeda who attacked us) and how Bush was taking his eye off the ball by invading Iraq.
Whether or not one agrees with that sentiment, I don't think he's ever changed his position since and I think he's very committed to resolving the Afghanistan front. Of course there's plenty of possibilities to screw it up no matter how committed one is to such things. Lyndon Johnson and the Vietnam war comes to mind here. I certainly wish Obama the best and most peaceful solution, but if anything will bring him down politically it will be the Afghanistan/Pakistan/Al Qeda problem. He already pretty much owns the GOP from here on out on domestic issues after beating their asses on HCR - even if they do gain a few seats as is always expected of the party out of power on midterms.
-Mo
|
I will fight your gods for food,
Mo Enzyme
(consolidation of handles: Jake Sapiens; memelab; logicnazi; Loki; Every1Hz; and Shadow)
|
|
|
|
Logged
